2007 Web Browser Eval Team
From Provider Wiki
This page has been created by the Spring 2007 Web Browser Evaluation Team as a place to collaborate and collect documentation and resources for the team.
The 2007 Web Browser Evaluation Team is working together from April 4 through mid-May (or the end of May as needed for documentation). For more information on the evaluation, please visit the [2007 Web Browser Evaluation Team website].
Contents |
Team Members
Email list for group discussion: webbrowser2007 at isc.upenn.edu
- Elizabeth Scheyder, SAS Computing, scheydec@sas (team co-lead)
- Rob Short, ISC TSS, rshort@isc (team co-lead)
- Jonathon Baron, Psychiatry, baron@psych (email participation only)
- Ryan Butkus, ISC N&T, rnb@isc
- Tad Davis, ISC AIT, davist@isc
- Clarence Din, SAS, din@sas
- Dan Dougherty, ISC TSS, dandough@pobox
- Ian Kelley, CHC, ikelley@pobox
- Larry Macy, Psychiatry, macy@bbl.med (email participation only)
- Barbara McAleese, Penn CVI, mcaleese@mail.med
- John Merz, CHC, jmerz@pobox
- Steve Minicola, University Communications, minicola@pobox
- Charles Rejonis, Wharton, rejonis@wharton
- Roz Robinson, Wharton, robinsonr@wharton
- Peter Shrom, ISC TSS, shrom@isc
- Bill Smith, CHC, wtsmith@pobox
- Scott Spitzer, SOM, spitzer@mail.med
- David Toccafondi, Library, davidtoc@pobox
Questions for the Team to Consider
- Overall team decisions on "Supported" and "Supported and Recommended" products
- IE7 on Vista is essentially a separate browser from IE7 on XP SP2 (coding and relation to the OS)
- Browsers to test
Evaluation Criteria/Things to Test
- Specific Penn web-vased applications (such as BEN Financials)
- Browser performance with POBOX Exchange
- CSS support
- xml support (http://www.psych.upenn.edu/~baron/153/p153a3.xml)
- svg support (http://www.psych.upenn.edu/~baron/153/p153a3.xml)
Products/Scenarios to Test and Results
- Notes
- Team members: put your name next to what you'll test
- Testing to take place either on your own machines or in the ISC Standards Lab
- There can be more than one tester per scenario, but please try to help fill out the missing links first (where possible)
- Test script is hosted online by SurveyMonkey - http://www.surveymonkey.com/s.asp?u=942363617774 - email Elizabeth (scheydec@sas) if you need the password
- Supplementary Test Script (added 4/20/07, just 2 questions) - http://www.surveymonkey.com/s.asp?u=759883682017 - same password
- Test results will automatically be collected by SurveyMonkey
- Testing Scenarios/Results
- Windows Vista with IE7 - Ryan Butkus, Scott Spitzer (SOM), Peter Shrom
- WIndows Vista with Firefox 2.x - Ryan Butkus, Charles Rejonis, Peter Shrom
- Windows XP SP2 with IE7 - Steve Minicola, Bill Smith
- Windows XP SP2 with IE6 - Tad Davis, Roz Robinson, Scott Spitzer (SOM)
- Windows XP SP2 with Firefox 2.x - Tad Davis, Steve Minicola
- Windows XP SP2 with Opera 9.10 - Tad Davis
- Mac OS X 10.3.9 with Safari 1.x - Rob Short, Elizabeth Scheyder
- Mac OS X 10.3.9 with Firefox 2.x - Tad Davis
- Mac OS X 10.4.9 with Safari 2.x - Tad Davis, Barbara McAleese, John Merz CHC
- Mac OS X 10.4.9 with Firefox 2.x - David Toccafondi, Barbara McAleese, Scott Spitzer (SOM)
- Mac OS X 10.5 (when released) with Safari 3.x - Larry Macy, Barbara McAleese
- Mac OS X 10.5 (when released) with Firefox 2.x - Larry Macy, Barbara McAleese
- Linux with Firefox 2.x - Baron
- Linux with Firefox 3 beta - Baron
Final Recommendations
- Supported and Recommended Products
- (make caveats and environment specific notes as needed)
Mac OS 10.3.9/10.4.x
- Firefox 2.0.0.x - supported & recommended
- Safari 1.2.x/2.0.x - supported & recommended
- Safari on 10.3.9 - no custom popup blocking
- Some Google tools (docs & spreadsheets, iGoogle) may be problematic with Safari
Windows XP SP2/Vista
- Firefox 2.0.0.x - supported & recommended
- Internet Explorer 7.0 - supported, but may become more important as Vista gains market share
- Internet Explorer 6.0 SP1 (Windows XP SP2 only) - supported specifically for Ben Financials and Business Objects users
- Supported Products
- (make caveats and environment specific notes as needed)
Documentation
- Penn web applications (placeholder)
- Configuration docs (placeholder)
Resources and News
- 4/20/07: Dell relents, offers Windows XP as consumer option: http://www.computerworld.com/action/article.do?command=viewArticleBasic&articleId=9017339&intsrc=news_ts_head
